Micro-Politics by Hesitation: How Combat Soldiers Work on and Against an Order to Kill

Authors

  • Thomas (Author) Scheffer Die Goethe Universit├Ąt Frankfurt am Main

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.1475803

Abstract

In the qualitative research on organisations, micro-politics and studies of work are dealt with in separate registers including distinct cases, concepts, and phenomena. Studies in micro-politics focus on the members' self-organizing tactics within dynamic relations of power. They seek to influence the power relations to their fractio's advantage. Studies of work focus on members' tricks of the trade preferably in demanding situations. Here, communities of practice develop methods and techniques to overcome recurring obstacles at work. The separation of the two microanalytics turns out to be little productive in moments when practical tasks become themselves doubtful, e.g. when order-takers (here, US-American soldiers) are persistently troubled by an order. For them, what to do next becomes methodically and tactically demanding. In the critical moments before the bombing, the soldiers hurry to change the order micro-politically, while getting ready to execute it. Can the subordinates work at all against the military order? The order-takers follow the order on the frontstage, while making provisions against it on the backstage. This twotrack policy, while failing to prevent the order, turns out to be productive nonetheless. It allows the soldiers to account for their work as dutiful and responsible.

Downloads

Published

31.10.2018

Issue

Section

Articles